Lessons to be learned
BAFSA’s Welsh representative Ritchie O’Connell wonders why a government that is so focused on school attendance is still playing with fire when it comes to amending BB100.
We are all very aware of recent prolonged partial or full closure of schools due to the presence of Reinforced Autoclaved Aerated Concrete (RAAC). This has not only affected students but has also had a huge impact on other community groups who may use school premises. Yet this level of disruption is not dissimilar to that caused by even a minor fire in a school and yet at every opportunity the UK Government fails to legislate to increase the resilience of school buildings when exposed to fire.
In their response to the consultation on the review of BB100, the National Association of Head Teachers (NAHT) stated:
‘Aside from the financial impact, school fires have also been shown to have a significant impact on the social and emotional experiences of pupils, staff and the wider community as well as on teaching and learning in the affected schools. The long-term disruption that follows puts staff and pupils under stress and imposes large financial, educational and administrative costs. Previous statistics on UK school fires have reported that they disrupt the education of an estimated 90,000 children and students annually.’
School fires in England are up on previous years, with an increase in both deliberate and accidental fires with accidental fires increasing by 16.67% to 427 fires in 2022/23 and, worryingly, deliberate fires also rising by 14.46%.
So why didn’t the UK Government take the opportunity of the recent review of BB100 to strengthen the requirement for automatic water-suppression systems? During the consultation they received submissions from the National Fire Chiefs Council, insurers and educators. Most responses took a similar view that the recommendations did not go far enough. The Association of School and College Leaders (ASCL) made the following observation in response:
Question 1: BB 100 recommends that automatic fire suppression systems should be installed in all new school buildings that have a storey with a finished floor level over 11m above ground level. Do you agree with this recommendation? If not, please explain why.
‘ASCL agrees in part with this recommendation. However, our members would prefer to see the requirement extended to all new school buildings, whether they are above 11m. This requirement is already in place in Wales and Scotland.’
According to the Government’s own data obtained via a Freedom of Information request, 248 new schools have been constructed since 2015, of which only 21 had sprinklers installed. Of the 468 major school refurbishments since 2015, only 69 had sprinklers installed. This equates to just 8.5% of new schools built since 2015 and 14.7% of majorly refurbished schools built since 2015 having sprinklers. This can hardly be described as representing ‘a few low-risk schools.’
Whilst the revised document is yet to be published, the consultation document, which in the absence of evidence to the contrary, is assumed to form the basis for the published document and falls significantly short of mandating for sprinklers in all new schools, opting instead for non-statutory guidance recommending automatic water suppression systems in:
- New school buildings that have a storey with a finished floor level over 11m above ground level
- New special schools
- New boarding accommodation
Of course, providing suppression in special schools and boarding schools is a welcome improvement, but I question how many new schools will have an occupied floor above 11m high. I suspect that a great many new schools will (purely by coincidence, you understand) now have a highest occupied floor at 10.99m high. Nothing arbitrary about though, eh? And don’t just take my word for it, the NFCC in their response to the BB100 consultation offer the following when considering the 11m recommended trigger height:
‘A recent search of planning databases by Zurich insurers showed that there are currently no schools planned that would meet this threshold, so the effects of this change are likely to be limited and appear to be a tokenistic gesture towards being able to state the consultation “mandates” sprinklers and thus improves safety.’
The consultation, if nothing changes pre-publication, represents a huge missed opportunity to mandate AWSS in all new schools in England, but hopefully it’s not too late for the UK Government to wake up and smell the coffee. Educators, insurers and firefighters have had their say and they have delivered a consistent message and that is that the proposals to amend BB100 do not go far enough. Sprinklers should be mandatory in all new or significantly altered schools – are you listening at the back?
School fires in England are up on previous years, with an increase in both deliberate and accidental fires with accidental fires increasing by 16.67% to 427 fires in 2022/23 and, worryingly, deliberate fires also rising by 14.46%.

BAFSA Sprinkler Saves submits report to NFCC ahead of Government decision on BB100
Ahead of the much-anticipated review of BB100 for England, BAFSA’s sprinkler ambassador, Nick Coleshill, compiled a report for the NFCC to form part of the industry’s case to Government to make sprinklers mandatory in all new schools in England as they are in Scotland and Wales.
The report detailed case studies where sprinklers have actuated and had an impact at educational premises. It covered 10 school sprinkler saves reported to the Sprinkler Saves UK website between November 2021 and May 2023. It also contains compound fire data focusing on 65 educational activations for the period 2018/19 to 2021/22 where sprinklers were present.
Secondary schools accounted for the highest number of incidents with half of the incidents cited as malicious with the location involving toilets or a changing room. To read the full report, go to https://www.bafsa.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2023/09/Reported-schoolsprinkler-activations-for-NC.pdf.
About the Author

Ritchie O'Connell
Ritchie O'Connell is BAFSA's Wales representative and is director of The Fire Practice - a fire engineering, fire risk assessment, training and safety consultancy
You must be logged in to post a comment.